Google Apps and Microsoft Office Live- Comparitive Study

In my last post I wrote about how to configure and use Google Apps for your domain. Office Live is the direct competition to Google Apps from Microsoft. Both of them have free versions and premium versions targeted for different sections. Even though the two services are targeted towards similar audiences, there are some very specific differences. Lets do a comparative study of the features.

Google Apps Microsoft Office Live

Microsoft Office Live Basics: Basics is the free version from Microsoft Office Live. The free version has the following features,

Microsoft Office Live Basics includes one FREE domain name for your business.
Access your mails, calenders, tasks etc. Allows to create 25 free email accounts with your domain and each email having 2GB of space.
Easy-to-use Web site design tools.
500 MB of Web site storage space.
Web site reports tool to analyze your traffic.

Now coming to the comparison with Google Apps,

Microsoft Office Live Basics gives you a free domain whereas Google Apps provides domain at 10$ from GoDaddy.
Google Apps allows you to create unlimited accounts whereas Office live Basics allows only 25 accounts for free version.
Microsoft Office Live would work well when all users run Windows, have copies of Microsoft Office, and use the latest versions of Internet Explorer whereas Google Apps can run on all OS and browsers (covers most of the popular ones). I tried to register for Office Live through Firefox and got an error message that Firefox is not supported.
Office Live has an excellent user interface when compared to Google’s basic HTML pages.
Office Live is available only for US, UK, France, Japan and Germany users, while Google Apps is available throughout the world (I could not register with Office Live because of this).
A valid credit card is required to complete the sign up process for Office Live. Although they don’t charge any amount for free version, they use it for authentication. Google Apps does not require any credit card for sign up.
The premium version of Google Apps cost around 50$ per user per year, whereas Office live costs you 19.95$ per month and it allows to create 50 users.

I feel if Office Live is available for all locations, then it would definitely give competition to Google Apps as it has good features and design and also the fact that unlimited accounts from Google Apps may not be useful for common users. The only major worrying fact about Office Live is fact that only Internet Explorer 6 and above is supported.

If you like to add any more comparison, please share it in comments.

Pingback: Technology Talk 19/08/07 | Technology Bites
http://notjustcricket.com RJ
A good comparision.
Looking at it from my personal perspective; No Firefox support kills Office Live, there and then! and on top of that the credit card being required, buries it finally.
If you notice, as an observation, recently a whole load of email spam has been generated pointing to apparently real websites, created on Office Live. It’s free, so anyone can go in, enter a credit card (begged, borrowed or stolen) and get a free domain, on Microsoft. All this gives an element of credibility to such spurious websites.
http://www.nirmaltv.com nirmaltv
@RJ,
Well said, Without Firefox support it can’t compete Google Apps. I never knew about this email spam from Office Live, but your concern is correct, anyone can get a free domain using some credit card.
http://www.reviewsaurus.com ReviewSaurus
Ah! that’s a nice difference. I agree that office live will make more impact, if at all they work on few things…the ones you’ve mentioned.
http://www.techiesden.com Vaibhav
INterface, the biggest thing to develop pages, If they have so great features then it might be the fist choice for professionals, But google might come with something great by seeing a handsome amount of competition from MS
http://www.siteguide.us Vijay
Microsoft have always made it a point to force the use of IE6+ for any user who needs a service from their site. That, probably is the only way they are going to boost up their dwindling IE numbers
http://www.sizzledcore.com Haris
I would go for Microsoft Office Live Basics only if it starts supporting all the browsers. Otherwise, Google is the best!
http://www.nirmaltv.com nirmaltv
@Vaibhav,
If you are more interested towards UI design, then Microsoft is better.
@Vijay,
Microsoft planning to make IE popular by this way, but this wont be successful unless Office live is that good. Lets wait and see.
@Harris,
Agree with you.
http://www.rishiraj.info Rishi
As Mayank said , Google is charging on spot but Microsoft is asking for credit card information for incase of emergency! So what is exactly the emergency?
http://www.nirmaltv.com nirmaltv
@Rishi,
The emergency could be attributed to the fact that the free domain could be misused to spam. In that case they would be able to track the person if he has used a valid credit card.
Pingback: Speed Linking #5
Pingback: Top 5 links from the Blogosphere by TechMantra
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/slickshow/ S!ick
Attempting to sign-up to MOLB was a nightmare: it wouldn’t take my Visa credit card, so I passed on it….
Pingback: htmlor’s blog » Microsoft Office Live Basics ??
http://www.mytailorstore.com custom tailor thailand
its really amazing that what i upload in google ,microsoft shows something different
http://www.mytailorstore.com vicky
different colors,different text in google and microsoft http://www.mytailorstore.com
Ashish
I really do not understand why we need to have multi-browser support in order to update the site. Of course, the multi-browser support is required for the deployed site.
Why can’t we use IE to administer the site created using Office Live. I love office live because the domain is free and they have some good tools for the site too.
http://fastercats.com Open Office and Google Docs
We http://www.fastercats.com have been customizing and deploying Open Office Suite 2.x using Google Docs for much the same thing… without the restrictions imposed by Microsoft’s licensing policy…
Karl A. Krogmann
Pingback: 4sysops - Microsoft Online Services - Move your Exchange and Sharepoint servers to the cloud?
http://microsoftofficefreedownload.weebly.com Microsoft Office Guru
I’ve been saying for some time that the main competitor to Microsoft Office in the next decade is going to be Gogle Docs and not Open Office or some other software alternative. In the near future all the documents are going to be in the “cloud”, as it enables much easier sharing and collaboration. The next big battle is going to be fought in the online world.